Josh

Building in the open

Note on Maybe Don’t Talk to the New York Times About Zohran Mamdani via Literary Hub

When writing to a journalist friend, I just said that it’s a bit unravelling, right now, to be on the receiving end of this kind of belated real-time education in elite metabolization. Like so many other bits of Times coverage, the whole of the piece is structured as an orchestrated encounter. Some people say this; however, others say this. It’s so offhand you can think you’re gazing through a pane of glass. Only when you stand a little closer, or when circumstances make you a little less blinkered, do you notice the fact which then becomes blinding and finally crazymaking, which is just that there is zero, less than zero, stress put on the relation between those two “sides,” or their histories, or their sponsors, or their relative evidentiary authority, or any of it. Instead, what you get is a piece making the various more or less bovine noises of studious grey-lady impartiality, with the labor of anything resembling “appraisal” surgically excised.

What a beautiful piece of writing.

I love a good dissection piece.

Keyboard Shortcuts

Key Action
o Source
e Edit
i Insight
r Random
h Home
s or / Search
Josh Beckman: https://www.joshbeckman.org/notes/962858501